<human>: Okay, so...very interested in the feedback of the general reddit audience. Especially women.

I'm a decent guy (not a Nice GuyTM), but a normally very respectful man in his 30's.  A couple months back I was single (broke up with girlfriend) and wanted to try an experiment as to how much play I would get if I changed my personality a bit.  I started approaching women with a more laid-back, arrogant style, talking myself up and teasing them (not mean, but more like mocking), not returning calls when I said I would.  Things like that.
I'm not sure why I did it other than I think I've always felt that standard resentment that the jerky guy always seems to get prettier women and more sex.  I know that's a sexist attitude and, believe me, I'm feeling some shame for this.
I want to be clear that this is NOT my usual style.  I'm generally outgoing, friendly, fairly silly, and responsible in my work/home life.  

The experiment blew up in my face. Some of you might say in a good way.  I had women I thought (way) out of my league calling me repeatedly and have had sex with over 10 since trying out the "new" personality.  This is more women than I've had in my entire life before this.  Sounds great to some of you?  Not so much for me.

I can't keep this up.  It's not me and I know that.  I'm kind of angry it worked so well, but I also know I'm not that asshole-guy to treat women this way.
Some of these women are really great and I'd like to maintain a friendship or continue dating, but NOW how do I back away from this fake person I've created?  I suppose it's not "fake" but another aspect of myself, but one I don't want to keep being.
How do I reveal who I really am without them thinking I'm a jerk for even trying this or having them drop me cause I'm NOT the jerk they want?

Give me a shortened version of the text
<bot>: Acted like an asshole for fun to pick up women and found it worked better than I planned.  How do I go back to my regular self and not look like a bigger jerk?