<human>: Ok, me and this girl, also 17, dated for about 10 months. She eventually started talking to another guy, which led to us breaking up. I moved on after about a month, but this past week, she has told me that she regrets breaking up with me, and that it was a giant mistake. She also told me that she wants to be friends with benefits. Being a 17 year old guy, I said yes, so now that's currently happening. But the thing is, I developed feelings for another girl after me and girl #1 broke up, even though I still have feelings for girl #1. I know the new girl would be extremely upset if she found out I was still even talking to girl #1.

I'm not really even sure what my question is to be honest, or if I even posted this to the right subreddit. But, the thing is, I have no one to talk to... My parents are the stereotypical southern bible thumpers, who would condemn ANY sexuality, at all. I really want to continue the thing with girl #1, but I know it won't help me move on from her... I would just love to hear advice from people on the outside, who won't immediately judge me. (I hope). Thank you in advance.

Can you succinctly summarize the text in 1-3 sentences?
<bot>: I want to be friends with benefits with an ex, feelings for new girl make the whole situation more confusing, and I'm not sure what to do...