<human>: Give me the gist of the text in a nutshell

Well about 4 months ago I finely told her I cared for her after felling that way for about 2 years.She said she didn't feel the same but she still cared for me.

[Conversation breakdown]
Me: I really really care for you.
Her: Aww that's sweet but I don't care the same for you.
Me: OK glad to get that off my chest, look at this funny video!

We go to the same church we live about two states apart, and get along well. 
She will only date people who are baptised (like her). I am not. 

I've started working out since the four months (doesnt have to do with her). 

I just need to know, should I try for it again next time I see her? I mean I think it would be hard for me to get over her, however I think I could if I met someone, or join the marines and let a drill sergeant drill it it out of me.
<bot>: Told life long friend I like her, got friend zoned big time, I want to try again. Advice or suggestions?