text:
Informal sector
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
The informal sector, informal economy, or grey economy[1][2] is the part of an economy that is neither taxed nor monitored by any form of government. Unlike the formal economy, activities of the informal economy are not included in a country's gross national product (GNP) or gross domestic product (GDP).[3] The informal sector can be described as a grey market in labour.
Other concepts that can be characterized as informal sector can include the black market (shadow economy, underground economy), agorism, and System D. Associated idioms include "under the table", "off the books", and "working for cash".
Although the informal sector makes up a significant portion of the economies in developing countries, it is often stigmatized as troublesome and unmanageable. However, the informal sector provides critical economic opportunities for the poor[3][4] and has been expanding rapidly since the 1960s.[5] As such, integrating the informal economy into the formal sector is an important policy challenge.[3]
Contents
[hide]
1 Definition
1.1 Characteristics
2 History
3 Statistics
3.1 Estimated size of countries' informal economy
3.2 Comparison of shadow economies in EU countries according to estimates by Friedrich Schneider
4 Social and political implications and issues
4.1 Gender
4.2 Political power of agents
4.3 Poverty
4.4 Children and child labour
5 Expansion and growth
6 Policy suggestions
7 See also
8 References
9 Further reading
10 External links
Definition[edit]
Black market peddler on graffiti, Kharkiv
The original use of the term 'informal sector poes' is attributed to the economic development model put forward by W. Arthur Lewis, used to describe employment or livelihood generation primarily within the developing world. It was used to describe a type of employment that was viewed as falling outside of the modern industrial sector.[6] An alternative definition uses job security as the measure of formality, defining participants in the informal economy as those "who do not have employment security, work security and social security".[7] While both of these definitions imply a lack of choice or agency in involvement with the informal economy, participation may also be driven by a wish to avoid regulation or taxation. This may manifest as unreported employment, hidden from the state for tax, social security or labour law purposes, but legal in all other aspects.[8] Edgar L. Feige has proposed a taxonomy for describing unobserved economies including the informal economy as being characterized by some form of non-compliant behavior with an institutional set of rules.[9] Feige argues that circumvention of labor market regulations specifying minimum wages, working conditions, social security, unemployment and disability benefits gives rise to an informal economy that deprives some workers of deserved benefits while conveying undeserved benefits to others.
The term is also useful in describing and accounting for forms of shelter or living arrangements that are similarly unlawful, unregulated, or not afforded protection of the state. 'Informal economy' is increasingly replacing 'informal sector'[3] as the preferred descriptor for this activity.
Informality, both in housing and livelihood generation has often been seen as a social ill, and described either in terms of what participant's lack, or wish to avoid. A countervailing view, put forward by prominent Dutch sociologist Saskia Sassen is that the modern or new 'informal' sector is the product and driver of advanced capitalism and the site of the most entrepreneurial aspects of the urban economy, led by creative professionals such as artists, architects, designers and software developers.[10] While this manifestation of the informal sector remains largely a feature of developed countries, increasingly systems are emerging to facilitate similarly qualified people in developing countries to participate.[11]
Characteristics[edit]
Street vendor in Colombia
Waste picker in Indonesia
Street vendor in India
The informal sector is largely characterized by several qualities: easy entry, meaning anyone who wishes to join the sector can find some sort of work which will result in cash earnings, a lack of stable employer-employee relationships,[12] a small scale of operations, and skills gained outside of a formal education.[3] Workers who participate in the informal economy are typically classified as employed. The type of work that makes up the informal economy is diverse, particularly in terms of capital invested, technology used, and income generated.[3][12] The spectrum ranges from self-employment or unpaid family labor[12] to street vendors, shoe shiners, and junk collectors.[3] On the higher end of the spectrum are upper-tier informal activities such as small-scale service or manufacturing businesses, which have more limited entry.[3][12] The upper-tier informal activities have higher set-up costs, which might include complicated licensing regulations, and irregular hours of operation.[12] However, most workers in the informal sector, even those are self-employed or wage workers, do not have access to secure work, benefits, welfare protection, or representation.[4] These features differ from businesses and employees in the formal sector which have regular hours of operation, a regular location and other structured benefits.[12]
The most prevalent types of work in the informal economy are home-based workers and street vendors. Home-based workers are more numerous while street vendors are more visible. Combined, the two fields make up about 10–15% of the non-agricultural workforce in developing countries and over 5% of the workforce in developed countries.[4]
While participation in the informal sector can be stigmatized, many workers engage in informal ventures by choice, for either economic or non-economic reasons. Economic motivations include the ability to evade taxes, the freedom to circumvent regulations and licensing requirements, and the capacity to maintain certain government benefits.[13] A study of informal workers in Costa Rica illustrated other economic reasons for staying in the informal sector, as well as non-economic factors. First, they felt they would earn more money through their informal sector work than at a job in the formal economy. Second, even if workers made less money, working in the informal sector offered them more independence, the chance to select their own hours, the opportunity to work outside and near friends, etc. While jobs in the formal economy might bring more security and regularity, or even pay better, the combination of monetary and psychological rewards from working in the informal sector proves appealing for many workers.[14]
The informal sector was historically recognized as an opposition to formal economy, meaning it included all income earning activities beyond legally regulated enterprises. However, this understanding is too inclusive and vague, and certain activities that could be included by that definition are not considered part of the informal economy. As the International Labour Organization defined the informal sector in 2002, the informal sector does not include the criminal economy. While production or employment arrangements in the informal economy may not be strictly legal, the sector produces and distributes legal goods and services. The criminal economy produces illegal goods and services.[4] The informal economy also does not include the reproductive or care economy, which is made up of unpaid domestic work and care activities. The informal economy is part of the market economy, meaning it produces goods and services for sale and profit. Unpaid domestic work and care activities do not contribute to that, and as a result, are not a part of the informal economy.[4]
History[edit]
Black market in Shinbashi, Japan, 1946
Governments have tried to regulate aspects of their economies for as long as surplus wealth has existed which is at least as early as Sumer. Yet no such regulation has ever been wholly enforceable. Archaeological and anthropological evidence strongly suggests that people of all societies regularly adjust their activity within economic systems in attempt to evade regulations. Therefore, if informal economic activity is that which goes unregulated in an otherwise regulated system then informal economies are as old as their formal counterparts, if not older. The term itself, however, is much more recent. The optimism of the modernization theory school of development had led most people in the 1950s and 1960s to believe that traditional forms of work and production would disappear as a result of economic progress in developing countries. As this optimism proved to be unfounded, scholars turned to study more closely what was then called the traditional sector. They found that the sector had not only persisted, but in fact expanded to encompass new developments. In accepting that these forms of productions were there to stay, scholars and some international organizations quickly took up the term informal sector (later known as the informal economy or just informality), which is credited to the British anthropologist Keith Hart in a 1971 study on Ghana published in 1973, and was coined by the International Labour Organization in a widely read study on Kenya in 1972.[15]
In "The Underground Economies: Tax Evasion and Information Distortion" Edgar L. Feige examined the economic implications of a shift of economic activity from the observed to the non-observed sector of the economy. Such a shift not only reduces the government's ability to collect revenues, it can also bias the nation's information systems and therefore lead to misguided policy decisions. The book examines alternative means of estimating the size of various unobserved economies and examines their consequences in both socialist and market oriented economies.[16] Feige goes on to develop a taxonomic framework that clarifies the distinctions between informal, illegal, unreported and unrecorded economies, and identifies their conceptual and empirical linkages and the alternative means of measuring their size and trends.[17] Since then the informal sector has become an increasingly popular subject of investigation, not just in economics, but also in sociology, anthropology and urban planning. With the turn towards so called post-fordist modes of production in the advanced developing countries, many workers were forced out of their formal sector work and into informal employment. In a seminal collection of articles, The Informal Economy. Studies in Advanced and Less Developed Countries, Alejandro Portes and collaborators emphasized the existence of an informal economy in all countries by including case studies ranging from New York City and Madrid to Uruguay and Colombia.[18]
Arguably one of the more influential books on the informal economy is Hernando de Soto's El otro sendero (1986),[19] which was published in English in 1989 as The Other Path with a preface by Peruvian writer Mario Vargas Llosa.[20] De Soto and his team argue that excessive regulation in the Peruvian (and other Latin American) economies force a large part of the economy into informality and thus prevent economic development. While accusing the ruling class of 20th century mercantilism, de Soto admires the entrepreneurial spirit of the informal economy. In a widely cited experiment, his team tried to legally register a small garment factory in Lima. This took more than 100 administrative steps and almost a year of full-time work. Feige's review of the Other Path places the work in the context of the informal economy literature.[21] Whereas de Soto's work is popular with policymakers and champions of free market policies like The Economist, some scholars of the informal economy have criticized it both for methodological flaws and normative bias.[22]
In the second half of the 1990s many scholars have started to consciously use the term "informal economy" instead of "informal sector" to refer to a broader concept that includes enterprises as well as employment in developing, transition, and advanced industrialized economies.
Among the surveys about the size and development of the shadow economy (mostly expressed in percent of official GDP) are those by Feige (1989), and Schneider and Enste (2000). In these surveys an intensive discussion about the various estimation procedures of the size of the shadow economy as well as a critical evaluation of the size of the shadow economy and the consequences of the shadow economy on the official one can be found.[23][24] The most recent survey paper on the subject[25] reviews the meaning and measurement of unobserved economies and is particularly critical of estimates of the size of the so-called "shadow economy" that employ Multiple Indicator multiple cause methods which treat the shadow economy as a latent variable.
Statistics[edit]
The Narantuul Market in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia, colloquially also called Khar Zakh (Black Market)
The informal economy under any governing system is diverse and includes small-scaled, occasional members (often street vendors and garbage recyclers) as well as larger, regular enterprises (including transit systems such as that of Lima, Peru). Informal economies include garment workers working from their homes, as well as informally employed personnel of formal enterprises. Employees working in the informal sector can be classified as wage workers, non-wage workers, or a combination of both.[5]
Statistics on the informal economy are unreliable by virtue of the subject, yet they can provide a tentative picture of its relevance. For example, informal employment makes up 58.7% of non-agricultural employment in Middle East - North Africa, 64.6% in Latin America, 79.4% in Asia, and 80.4% in sub-Saharan Africa.[26] If agricultural employment is included, the percentages rise, in some countries like India and many sub-Saharan African countries beyond 90%. Estimates for developed countries are around 15%.[4] In recent surveys, the informal economy in many regions has declined over the past 20 years to 2014. In Africa, the share of the informal economy has decreased to an estimate of around 40% of the economy.[27]
In developing countries, the largest part of informal work, around 70%, is self-employed. Wage employment predominates. The majority of informal economy workers are women. Policies and developments affecting the informal economy have thus a distinctly gendered effect.
Estimated size of countries' informal economy[edit]
To estimate the size and development of any underground or shadow economy is quite a challenging task since participants in such economies attempt to hide their behaviors. One must also be very careful to distinguish whether one is attempting to measure the unreported economy, normally associated with tax evasion,[28] or the unrecorded or non observed economy,[29] associated with the amount of income that is readily excluded from national income and produce accounts due to the difficulty of measurement. There are numerous estimates of tax noncompliance as measured by tax gaps produced by audit methods or by "top down" methods[30] Friedrich Schneider and several co-authors[31] claim to have estimated the size and trend of what they call the "shadow economy" worldwide by a currency demand /MIMIC model approach that treats the "shadow economy" as a latent variable.Trevor S. Breusch has critiqued this work warning the profession that" The literature applying this model to the underground economy abounds with alarming Procrustean tendencies. Various kinds of sliding and scaling of the results are carried out in the name of "benchmarking", although these operations are not always clearly documented. The data are typically transformed in ways that are not only undeclared but have the unfortunate effect of making the results of the study sensitive to the units in which the variables are measured. The complexity of the estimation procedure, together with its deficient documentation, leave the reader unaware of how these results have been shorted to fit the bed of prior belief. There are many other results in circulation for various countries, for which the data cannot be identified and which are given no more documentation than "own calculations by the MIMIC method". Readers are advised to adjust their valuation of these estimates accordingly.[32] Edgar L. Feige[33] finds that Schneider's shadow economy "estimates suffer from conceptual flaws, apparent manipulation of results and insufficient documentation for replication, questioning their place in the academic, policy and popular literature".
Comparison of shadow economies in EU countries according to estimates by Friedrich Schneider[edit]
German shadow economy 1975–2015, Friedrich Schneider University Linz[34]
Since the establishment of the Single Market (Maastricht 1993) the total EU shadow economy has been growing systematically to approx. 1.9 trillions € in preparation of the EURO[35] driven by the motor of the European shadow economy, Germany, which has been generating approx. 350 bn € per annum[34] since then (see also diagram on the right). Hence, the EU financial economy has developed parallel an efficient tax haven bank system to protect and manage its growing shadow economy. As per the Financial Secrecy Index (FSI 2013)[36] currently Germany and some neighbouring countries, range among the world's top tax haven countries.
The diagram below clearly shows that national informal economies per capita vary only moderately in most EU countries. It is because market sectors with high informal part (above 45%)[37] like "building and construction" or "agriculture" are rather homogeneously distributed over the countries, whereas sectors with low informal part (below 30%)[37] like "financial and business" (in Switzerland, Luxembourg), "public and personal services" (in Scandinavian countries) as well as "retail, wholesale and repair" are dominant in countries with extremely high GDP per capita i.e. industrially highly developed countries. The diagram also shows that in absolute numbers the shadow economy per capita is related to the wealth of a society (GDP). Generally spoken, the higher GDP the higher shadow economy, albeit non-proportional.
There is a direct relation between high self-employment of a country to its above average shadow economy.[38] In highly industrialized countries where shadow economy (per capita) is high and the huge private sector is shared by an extremely small elite of entrepreneurs a considerable part of tax evasion is practised by a much smaller number of (elite) people. As an example German shadow economy in 2013 was 4.400 € per capita, which was the 9th highest place in EU, whereas according to OECD only 11.2% of employed people were self-employed (place 18).[39] On the other hand, Greece's shadow economy was only 3.900 € p.c (place 13) but self-employment was 36.9% (place 1).
An extreme example of shadow economy camouflaged by the financial market is Luxembourg where the relative annual shadow economy is only 8% of the GDP which is the second lowest percentage (2013) of all EU countries whereas its absolute size (6.800 € per capita) is the highest.
Map of the national shadow economies per capita in EU countries. The red scale represents the numbers displayed by the red bars of the diagram on the left.
Social and political implications and issues[edit]
According to development and transition theories, workers in the informal sector typically earn less income, have unstable income, and do not have access to basic protections and services.[41][42] The informal economy is also much larger than most people realize, with women playing a huge role. The working poor, particularly women, are concentrated in the informal economy, and most low-income households rely on the sector to provide for them.[4] However, informal businesses can also lack the potential for growth, trapping employees in menial jobs indefinitely. On the other hand, the informal sector can allow a large proportion of the population to escape extreme poverty and earn an income that is satisfactory for survival.[43] Also, in developed countries, some people who are formally employed may choose to perform part of their work outside of the formal economy, exactly because it delivers them more advantages. This is called 'moonlighting'. They derive social protection, pension and child benefits and the like, from their formal employment, and at the same time have tax and other advantages from working on the side.
From the viewpoint of governments, the informal sector can create a vicious cycle. Being unable to collect taxes from the informal sector, the government may be hindered in financing public services, which in turn makes the sector more attractive. Conversely, some governments view informality as a benefit, enabling excess labor to be absorbed, and mitigating unemployment issues.[43] Recognizing that the informal economy can produce significant goods and services, create necessary jobs, and contribute to imports and exports is critical for governments.[4]
The workers are not entitled to social security.
The workers in informal sector cannot form trade union.
Gender[edit]
A group of Indian women making bamboo products they intend to sell in Dumka, Jharkhand
A girl selling plastic containers for carrying Ganges water, Haridwar, India
Women tend to make up the greatest portion of the informal sector, often ending up in the most erratic and corrupt segments of the sector.[41] In developing countries, most of the female non-agricultural labor force is in the informal sector.[44] Major occupations in the informal sector include home-based workers (such as dependent subcontract workers, independent own account producers, and unpaid workers in family businesses) and street vendors, which both are classified in the informal sector.[45] In India, women working in the informal sector often work as ragpickers, domestic workers, coolies, vendors, beauticians, construction laborers, and garment workers.
Female representation in the informal sector is attributed to a variety of factors. One such factor is that employment in the informal sector is the source of employment that is most readily available to women.[45] A 2011 study of poverty in Bangladesh noted that cultural norms, religious seclusion, and illiteracy among women in many developing countries, along with a greater commitment to family responsibilities, prevent women from entering the formal sector.[46]
According to a 2002 study commissioned by the ILO, the connection between employment in the informal economy and being poor is stronger for women than men.[5] While men tend to be over-represented in the top segment of the informal sector, women overpopulate the bottom segment.[5][41] Men are more likely to have larger-scale operations and deal in non-perishable items while few women are employers who hire others.[5] Instead, women are more likely to be involved in smaller-scale operations and trade food items.[5] Women are under-represented in higher-income employment positions in the informal economy and over-represented in lower-income statuses.[5] As a result, the gender gap in terms of wage is higher in the informal sector than the formal sector.[5] Labor markets, household decisions, and states all propagate this gender inequality.[41]
Political power of agents[edit]
Workers in the informal economy lack a significant voice in government policy.[13] Not only is the political power of informal workers limited, but the existence of the informal economy creates challenges for other politically influential actors. For example, the informal workforce is not a part of any trade union, nor does there seem a push or inclination to change that status. Yet the informal economy negatively affects membership and investment in the trade unions. Laborers who might be formally employed and join a union for protection may choose to branch out on their own instead. As a result, trade unions are inclined to oppose the informal sector, highlighting the costs and disadvantages of the system. Producers in the formal sector can similarly feel threatened by the informal economy. The flexibility of production, low labor and production costs, and bureaucratic freedom of the informal economy can be seen as consequential competition for formal producers, leading them to challenge and object to that sector. Last, the nature of the informal economy is largely anti-regulation and free of standard taxes, which diminishes the material and political power of government agents. Whatever the significance of these concerns are, the informal sector can shift political power and energies.[13]
Poverty[edit]
Informal vendors in Uttar Pradesh
The relationship between the informal sectors and poverty certainly is not simple nor does a clear, causal relationship exist. An inverse relationship between an increased informal sector and slower economic growth has been observed though.[41] Average incomes are substantially lower in the informal economy and there is a higher preponderance of impoverished employees working in the informal sector.[47] In addition, workers in the informal economy are less likely to benefit from employment benefits and social protection programs.[4] For instance, a survey in Europe shows that the respondents who have difficulties to pay their household bills have worked informally more often in the past year than those that do not (10% versus 3% of the respondents).[48]
Children and child labour[edit]
This section possibly contains original research. Please improve it by verifying the claims made and adding inline citations. Statements consisting only of original research should be removed. (April 2018) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
A girl weaving a rug in Egypt
Children work in the informal economy in many parts of the world. They often work as scavengers (collecting recyclables from the streets and dump sites), day laborers, cleaners, construction workers, vendors, in seasonal activities, domestic workers, and in small workshops; and often work under hazardous and exploitative conditions. [49][50] It is common for children to work as domestic servants across Latin America and parts of Asia. Such children are very vulnerable to exploitation: often they are not allowed to take breaks or are required to work long hours; many suffer from a lack of access to education, which can contribute to social isolation and a lack of future opportunity. UNICEF considers domestic work to be among the lowest status, and reports that most child domestic workers are live-in workers and are under the round-the-clock control of their employers.[51] Some estimates suggest that among girls, domestic work is the most common form of employment.[52]
During times of economic crisis many families experience unemployment and job loss, thus compelling adolescents to supplement their parents’ income by selling goods or services to contribute to the family economy. At the core, youth must compromise their social activities with other youth, and instead prioritize their participation in the informal economy, thus manufacturing a labor class of adolescents who must take on an adult role within the family. Although it revolves around a negative stigma of deviance, for a majority of individuals, mostly people of color, the informal economy is not an ideal choice but a necessity for survival. Participating in the informal economy is becoming normalized due to the lack of resources available in low-income and marginalized communities, and no matter how hard they have to work, will not advance in the economic hierarchy. When a parent is either unemployed or their job is on low demand, they are compelled to find other methods to provide for themselves but most importantly their children. Yet, due to all the limitations and the lack of jobs, children eventually cooperate with their parent/s and also work for their family's economic well-being. By having to assist in providing for the family, children miss out on their childhood because instead of engaging in activities other youth their age participate in, they are obligated to take on an adult role, put the family first and contribute to the family's well-being.
The participation of adolescents in the informal economy, is a contentious issue due to the restrictions and laws in place for youth have to work. One of the main dilemmas that arise when children engage in this type of work, is that privileged adults, denounce children participation as forced labor. Due to the participant being young, the adults are viewed as “bad” parents because first they cannot provide for their children, second they are stripping the child from a “normal” childhood, and third, child labor is frowned upon. Furthermore, certain people believe that children should not be working because children do not know the risks and the pressure of working and having so much responsibility, but the reality is that for most families, the children are not being forced to work, rather they choose to help sustain their family’s income. The youth become forced by their circumstances, meaning that because of their conditions, they do not have much of a choice. Youth have the capability to acknowledge their family’s financial limitations and many feel that it is their moral obligation to contribute to the family income. Thus, they end up working without asking for an allowance or wage, because kids recognize that their parents cannot bring home enough income alone, thus their contribution is necessary and their involvement becomes instrumental for their family's economic survival.[53]
Emir Estrada and Pierrette Hondagneu-Sotelo have gone to predominantly Latinx communities of Los Angeles, CA. to observe the daily actions of street vendors. They analyze why adults participate in the informal economy. Although it revolves around a negative stigma of deviance, for a majority of individuals, the informal economy is not an ideal choice but an action necessary for survival. While witnessing the constant struggle of Latinx individuals to make ends meet and trying to earn money to put food on the table, they witnessed how the participation of children either benefits the family or even hurt it. Through field notes derived from their participation, Estrada states, “children are not the ‘baggage’ that adult immigrants simply bring along. In the case of street vendors, we see that they are also contributors to family processes”.[54] Estrada's findings demonstrate that children are working in order to help contribute to their household income, but most importantly, they play a vital role when it comes to language barriers. The kids are not simply workers, they achieve an understanding of how to manage a business and commerce.
Expansion and growth[edit]
The division of the economy into formal and informal sectors has a long heritage. Arthur Lewis in his seminal work Economic Development with Unlimited Supply of Labour, published in the 1950s, was the celebrated paradigm of development for the newly independent countries in the 1950s and 1960s. The model assumed that the unorganized sector with the surplus labour will gradually disappear as the surplus labour gets absorbed in the organised sector. The Lewis model is drawn from the experience of capitalist countries in which the share of agriculture and unorganized sector showed a spectacular decline, but it didn't prove to be true in many developing countries, including India. On the other hand, probabilistic migration models developed by Harris and Todaro in the 1970s envisaged the phenomenon of the informal sector as a transitional phase through which migrants move to the urban centers before shifting to formal sector employment. Hence it is not a surprise to see policy invisibility in the informal sector. Curiously, the informal sector does not find a permanent place in the Marxian theory since they anticipate the destruction of the pre-capitalist structure as a result of the aggressive growth of capitalism. To them, in the course of development, 'the small fish is being eaten by the big fish'. Therefore, neither in the Marxian theory nor in the classical economic theory, the unorganized sector holds a permanent place in the economic literature.[55]
The informal sector has been expanding as more economies have started to liberalize.[41] This pattern of expansion began in the 1960s when a lot of developing countries didn't create enough formal jobs in their economic development plans, which led to the formation of an informal sector that didn't solely include marginal work and actually contained profitable opportunities.[5] In the 1980s, the sector grew alongside formal industrial sectors. In the 1990s, an increase in global communication and competition led to a restructuring of production and distribution, often relying more heavily on the informal sector.[5]
Over the past decade, the informal economy is said to account for more than half of the newly created jobs in Latin America. In Africa it accounts for around eighty percent.[5] Many explanations exist as to why the informal sector has been expanding in the developing world throughout the past few decades. It is possible that the kind of development that has been occurring has failed to support the increased labor force in a formal manner. Expansion can also be explained by the increased subcontracting due to globalization and economic liberalization. Finally, employers could be turning toward the informal sector to lower costs and cope with increased competition.
Such extreme competition between industrial countries occurred after the expansion of the EC to markets of the then new member countries Greece, Spain and Portugal, and particularly after the establishment of the Single European Market (1993, Treaty of Maastricht). Mainly for French and German corporations it led to systematic increase of their informal sectors under liberalized tax laws, thus fostering their mutual competitiveness and against small local competitors. The continuous systematic increase of the German informal sector was stopped only after the establishment of the EURO and the execution of the Summer Olympic Games 2004,[34] which has been the first and (up to now) only in the Single Market. Since then the German informal sector stabilized on the achieved 350 bn € level which signifies an extremely high tax evasion for a country with 90% salary-employment.
According to the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (SIDA), the key drivers for the growth of the informal economy in the twenty-first century include:[3]
limited absorption of labour, particularly in countries with high rates of population or urbanisation
excessive cost and regulatory barriers of entry into the formal economy, often motivated by corruption
weak institutions, limiting education and training opportunities as well as infrastructure development
increasing demand for low-cost goods and services
migration motivated by economic hardship and poverty
difficulties faced by women in gaining formal employment
Historically, development theories have asserted that as economies mature and develop, economic activity will shift from the informal to the formal sphere. In fact, much of the economic development discourse is centered around the notion that formalization indicates how developed a country's economy is; for more on this discussion see the page on fiscal capacity.[56] However, evidence suggests that the progression from informal to formal sectors is not universally applicable. While the characteristics of a formalized economy – full employment and an extensive welfare system – have served as effective methods of organizing work and welfare for some nations, such a structure is not necessarily inevitable or ideal. Indeed, development appears to be heterogeneous in different localities, regions, and nations, as well as the type of work practiced.[3][56] For example, at one end of the spectrum of the type of work practiced in the informal economy are small-scale businesses and manufacturing; on the other "street vendors, shoe shiners, junk collectors and domestic servants."[3] Regardless of how the informal economy develops, its continued growth that it cannot be considered a temporary phenomenon.[3]
Policy suggestions[edit]
Informal beverage vendor in Guatemala City
As it has been historically stigmatized, policy perspectives viewed the informal sector as disruptive to the national economy and a hindrance to development.[57] The justifications for such criticisms include viewing the informal economy as a fraudulent activity that results in a loss of revenue from taxes, weakens unions, creates unfair competition, leads to a loss of regulatory control on the government's part, reduces observance of health and safety standards, and reduces the availability of employment benefits and rights. These characteristics have led to many nations pursuing a policy of deterrence with strict regulation and punitive procedures.[57]
In a 2004 report, the Department for Infrastructure and Economic Cooperation under SIDA explained three perspectives on the role of government and policy in relation to the informal economy.[3]
Markets function efficiently on their own; government interference would only lead to inefficiency and dysfunction.
The informal economy functions outside of government control, largely because those who participate wish to avoid regulation and taxation.
The informal economy is enduring; suitable regulation and policies are required.
As informal economy has significant job creation and income generation potential, as well as the capacity to meet the needs of poor consumers by providing cheaper and more accessible goods and services, many stakeholders subscribe to the third perspective and support government intervention and accommodation.[3][58] Embedded in the third perspective is the significant expectation that governments will revise policies that have favored the formal sphere at the expense of the informal sector.[3]
Theories of how to accommodate the informal economy argue for government policies that, recognizing the value and importance of the informal sector, regulate and restrict when necessary but generally work to improve working conditions and increase efficiency and production.[3]
The challenge for policy interventions is that so many different types of informal work exist; a solution would have to provide for a diverse range of circumstances.[41] A possible strategy would be to provide better protections and benefits to informal sector players. However, such programs could lead to a disconnect between the labor market and protections, which would not actually improve informal employment conditions.[41] In a 2014 report monitoring street vending, WIEGO suggested urban planners and local economic development strategists study the carrying capacity of areas regularly used by informal workers and deliver the urban infrastructure necessary to support the informal economy, including running water and toilets, street lights and regular electricity, and adequate shelter and storage facilities.[58] That study also called for basic legal rights and protections for informal workers, such as appropriate licensing and permit practices.[58]
An ongoing policy debate considers the value of government tax breaks for household services such cleaning, babysitting and home maintenance, with an aim to reduce the shadow economy's impact. There are currently systems in place in Sweden[59] and France[60] which offer 50 percent tax breaks for home cleaning services. There has also been debate in the UK about introducing a similar scheme, with potentially large savings for middle-class families and greater incentive for women to return to work after having children.[61] The European Union has used political measures to try and curb the shadow economy. Although no definitive solution has been established to date, the EU council has led dialogue on a platform that would combat undeclared work.[62]
See also[edit]
Sustainable development portal
Agorism
Casual employment
Counter-economics
Doing business as
Informal housing
Legal personality, a requirement for legitimate businesses
Rotating Savings and Credit Association
Substantivism
System D
Virtual economy
References[edit]
Jump up ^ Calbreath, Dean. "Hidden economy a hidden danger". U-T San Diego. Retrieved 4 March 2015.
Jump up ^ "Economics focus: In the shadows". The Economist. Retrieved 4 March 2015.
^ Jump up to: a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p "The Informal Economy: Fact Finding Study" (PDF). Department for Infrastructure and Economic Cooperation. Retrieved 20 November 2011.
^ Jump up to: a b c d e f g h i Women and Men in the Informal Economy (PDF). International Labour Organisation. 2002. ISBN 92-2-113103-3. Retrieved 2006-12-18.
^ Jump up to: a b c d e f g h i j k Carr, Marilyn and Martha A. Chen. 2001. "Globalization and the Informal Economy: How Global Trade and Investment Impact on the Working Poor". Background paper commissioned by the ILO Task Force on the Informal Economy. Geneva, Switzerland: International Labour Office.
Jump up ^ Lewis, William (1955). The Theory of Economic Growth. London: Allen and Unwin.
Jump up ^ Report on conditions of work and promotion of livelihoods in the unorganised sector. New Delhi: National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganised Sector. 2007.
Jump up ^ Williams, Colin C. (2005). A Commodified World?: Mapping the limits of capitalism. London: Zed Books. pp. 73, 74.
Jump up ^ Feige, Edgar L. (2016). "Reflections on the Meaning and Measurement of Unobserved Economies: What do we really know about the "Shadow Economy"?". Journal of Tax Administration (30/1).
Jump up ^ Jonatan Habib Engqvist and Maria Lantz, ed. (2009). Dharavi: documenting informalities. Delhi: Academic Foundation.
Jump up ^ Wilson, David (9 February 2012). "Jobs Giant: How Matt Barrie Build a Global Empire". The Age. Retrieved 20 March 2012.
^ Jump up to: a b c d e f Meier, Gerald M.; Rauch, James E. (2005). Leading Issues in Economic Development (8 ed.). New York: Oxford University Press. pp. 371–375.
^ Jump up to: a b c Gërxhani, Klarita (2004). "The Informal Sector in Developed and Less Developed Countries: A Literature Review". Public Choice. 120 (3/4): 267–300. doi:10.1023/b:puch.0000044287.88147.5e.
Jump up ^ Meier, Gerald M.; Rauch, James E. (2005). Leading Issues in Economic Development (8 ed.). New York: Oxford University Press. p. 373.
Jump up ^ Hart, Keith (1973). "Informal income opportunities and urban employment in Ghana". The Journal of Modern African Studies. 11 (3): 61–89. doi:10.1017/s0022278x00008089. JSTOR 159873.
Jump up ^ Feige, Edgar L. (1989). The Underground Economies:Tax Evasion and Information Distortion. Cambridge University Press.
Jump up ^ Feige, Edgar L. (December 11, 2003). "Defining and Estimating Underground and Informal Economies: The New Institutional Economics Approach". World Development. 18 (7): 989–1002. doi:10.1016/0305-750x(90)90081-8.
Jump up ^ Portes, Alejandro; Haller, William (2005). "The Informal Economy". In N. Smelser; R. Swedberg. Handbook of Economic Sociology, 2nd edition. Russell Sage Foundation.
Jump up ^ Hernando de Soto (1986). El Otro Sendero. Sudamericana. ISBN 950-07-0441-2.
Jump up ^ Hernando de Soto (1989). The Other Path: The Economic Answer to Terrorism. Harper Collins. ASIN 0465016103. ISBN 0-06-016020-9. CS1 maint: ASIN uses ISBN (link)
Jump up ^ Feige, Edgar L. (1989). pp. 371–379. "The Underground Wealth of Nations:Commentary on "The Other Path"". The World and I (June 1989).
Jump up ^ Davis, Mike (2006). Planet of Slums. London: Verso. pp. 79–82.
Jump up ^ Feige, E.L. (1989). The underground economies: Tax evasion and information distortion. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Jump up ^ Schneider, F.; Enste, D. (2000). pp. 77–114. "Shadow economies: Size, causes and consequences". Journal of Economic Literature (38/1).
Jump up ^ Feige, Edgar L. (2016). "The Meaning and Measurement of Unobserved Economies: What do we really know about the "Shadow Economy"?". Journal of Tax Administration (30/1).
Jump up ^ Charmes, Jacques. "The informal economy: Definitions, Size, Contribution, Characteristics and Trends", RNSF, Rome, 2016.
Jump up ^ "Africa's informal economy is receding faster than Latin America's". The Economist. Retrieved 2017-05-28.
Jump up ^ "Preliminary Estimates of the Tax Year 2006 Underreporting Gap" (PDF). Irs.gov. Retrieved 2016-10-20.
Jump up ^ "Measuring the Non-Observed Economy - A Handbook". OECD. Retrieved 2016-10-20.
Jump up ^ [1][dead link]
Jump up ^ http:// www.econ.jku.at/.../Schneider_Bühn_Montenegro.pdf
Jump up ^ [2][dead link]
Jump up ^ Feige, Edgar L. (1 February 2016). "Reflections on the Meaning and Measurement of Unobserved Economies: What Do We Really Know About the 'Shadow Economy'". SSRN 2728060  . Missing or empty |url= (help)
^ Jump up to: a b c "• Schattenwirtschaft - Umfang in Deutschland bis 2016 | Statistik". De.statista.com. 2016-10-01. Retrieved 2016-10-20.
^ Jump up to: a b [3]
Jump up ^ [4]
^ Jump up to: a b Friedrich Schneider. "The Shadow Economy and Work in the Shadow : What Do We (Not) Know?" (PDF). Ftp.iza.org. Retrieved 2016-10-20.
Jump up ^ Friedrich Schneider. "Shadow Economies in Highly Developed OECD Countries : What Are the Driving Forces?" (PDF). Ftp.iza.org. Retrieved 2016-10-20.
Jump up ^ "Employment - Self-employment rate - OECD Data". Data.oecd.org. Retrieved 2016-10-20.
Jump up ^ Schneider, Friedrich (2013). The Shadow Economy in Europe. University of Linz.
^ Jump up to: a b c d e f g h UNRISD. 2010. "Gender Inequalities at Home and in the Market." Assignment: Chapter 4, pp. 5–33.
Jump up ^ Beneria, Lourdes and Maria S. Floro. 2006. "Labor Market Informalization, Gender and Social Protection: Reflections on Poor Urban Households in Bolivia, Ecuador and Thailand," in Shahra Razavi and Shireen Hassim, eds. Gender and Social Policy in a Global Context: Uncovering the Gendered Structure of "the Social," pp. 193–216. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
^ Jump up to: a b Garcia-Bolivar, Omar E. 2006. "Informal economy: is it a problem, a solution, or both? The perspective of the informal business.' Northwestern University School of : Law and Economics Papers. The Berkeley Electronic Press.
Jump up ^ Martha Alter Chen. "Women in the Informal Sector : A Global Picture, the Global Movement" (PDF). Cpahq.org. Retrieved 2016-10-20.
^ Jump up to: a b Chen, M (2001) "Women in the informal sector: a global picture, the global movementt." SAIS Review 21(1).
Jump up ^ Jahiruddin, ATM; Short, Patricia; Dressler, Wolfram; Khan, Adil (2011). "Can Microcredit Worsen Poverty? Cases of Exacerbated Poverty in Bangladesh". Development in Practice.
Jump up ^ Carr, Marilyn and Martha A. Chen. 2001. "Globalization and the Informal Economy: How Global Trade and Investment Impact on the Working Poor". Background paper commissioned by the ILO Task Force on the Informal Economy. Geneva, Switzerland: International Labour Office.
Jump up ^ European Commission. (2013). Undeclared work in the European Union. Retrieved from Brussels: European Commission
Jump up ^ "News-Stories – World Vision" (PDF). Worldvision.org. Retrieved 2016-10-20.
Jump up ^ "Decent work and the informal economy" (PDF). Ilo.org. Retrieved 2016-10-20.
Jump up ^ "Counting Cinderellas Child Domestic Servants – Numbers and Trends".
Jump up ^ "Child domestic workers: Finding a voice" (PDF). Antislavery.com. Retrieved October 4, 2013.
Jump up ^ Estrada, Emir; Hondagneu-Sotelo, Pierrette (2011). "Intersectional Dignities: Latino Immigrant Street Vendor Youth in Los Angeles". Journal of Contemporary Ethnography. 40 (1): 102–131. doi:10.1177/0891241610387926.
Jump up ^ Estrada, Emir. [2013 "Changing household dynamics: Children's American generational resources in street vending markets"] Check |url= value (help). Childhood. 20 (1): 51–65. doi:10.1177/0907568212458441.
Jump up ^ Justine George. "Informal Sector in India: A Review" (PDF). Mpra.ub.uni-muenmchen.de. Retrieved 2016-10-20.
^ Jump up to: a b Williams, Colin C.; Windebank, Jan (1998). Informal Employment in Advanced Economies: Implications for Work and Welfare. London: Routledge. p. 113.
^ Jump up to: a b Williams, Colin C. (2005). "The Undeclared Sector, Self-Employment and Public Policy". International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research. 11 (4): 244–257. doi:10.1108/13552550510603289.
^ Jump up to: a b c Roever, Sally (April 2014). "Informal Economy Monitoring Study Sector Report: Street Vendors" (PDF). Women in Informal Employment Globalizing and Organizing (WIEGO). Retrieved November 3, 2014.
Jump up ^ "Skattereduktion för rot- och rutarbete". Archived from the original on 11 July 2014. Retrieved 4 March 2015.
Jump up ^ "Impots.gouv.fr – L'emploi d'un salarié à domicile". Retrieved 4 March 2015.
Jump up ^ Ross, Tim (9 February 2012). "Tax breaks for hiring a cleaner could save middle class thousands". The Telegraph. Retrieved 17 July 2014.
Jump up ^ "Employment, Social Policy, Health and Consumer Affairs" (PDF) (Press release). 19 June 2014. Archived from the original (PDF) on 10 September 2014. Retrieved 17 July 2014.
Further reading[edit]
Enrique Ghersi (1997). "The Informal Economy in Latin America" (PDF). Cato Journal. Cato Institute. 17 (1). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2006-12-14. Retrieved 2006-12-18. An article by a collaborator of de Soto.
John C. Cross (January 1995). "Formalizing the informal economy: The Case of Street Vendors in Mexico City". Archived from the original on 2006-12-13. Retrieved 2006-12-18. A working paper describing attempts to formalize street vending in Mexico.
World Institute for Development Economics Research (September 17–18, 2004). Unlocking Human Potential. United Nations University. Archived from the original on 2006-11-30. Retrieved 2006-12-18.
Cervero, Robert (2000). Informal Transport in the Developing World. Nairobi: United Nations Centre for Human Settlements (HABITAT). ISBN 9211314534.
Douglas Uzzell (November 22, 2004). "A Homegrown Mass Transit System in Lima, Peru: A Case of Generative Planning". City & Society. 1 (1): 6–34. doi:10.1525/city.1987.1.1.6.
Cheats or Contributors? Self Employed People in the Informal Economy A report by east London Charity Community Links and Microfinance organisation Street UK providing analysis of the motivations of informal workers.
Need not Greed – People in low-paid informal work A report by east London Charity Community Links explores the experience of people on low incomes, doing informal paid work.
World Bank policy note on The Informality Trap: Tax Evasion, Finance, and Productivity in Brazil
World Bank policy note on Rising Informality – Reversing the Tide
Paper estimating the size of the informal economy in 110 developing, transition and developed countries
Keith Hart (2000). The Memory Bank. Profile Books. The link is to an online archive of Keith Hart's works.
Frey, B.S. (1989). How large (or small) should the underground economy be? In E.L. Feige (Ed.), The underground economy: Tax evasion and information distortion, 111–129. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Temkin, Benjamin (2009). "Informal Self-Employment in Developing Countries: Entrepreneurship or Survivalist Strategy? Some Implications for Public Policy". Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy. 9 (1).
Temkin, Benjamin; Jorge, Veizaga (2010). "The Impact of Economic Globalization on Labor Informality". New Global Studies. 4 (1). doi:10.2202/1940-0004.1083.
Temkin Benjamin, The Negative Influence of Labor Informality on Subjective Well-Being, Global Labor Journal, Vol 7, No. 1, (2016) DOI: https://doi.org/10.15173/glj.v7i1.2545
External links[edit]
"The Commission on Legal Empowerment of the Poor". United Nations Development Program. Archived from the original on 2007-02-09. Co-chaired by de Soto and former secretary of state Madeleine Albright.
The Americas: Decent work – a rarity – independent news reports and features about the world of labour in the Americas by IPS Inter Press Service
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Informal_sector&oldid=838070715"
Categories:
Informal economy
Economic sectors
Hidden categories:
CS1 maint: ASIN uses ISBN
All articles with dead external links
Articles with dead external links from October 2016
Pages using web citations with no URL
Pages with URL errors
Articles that may contain original research from April 2018
All articles that may contain original research
Navigation menu
Personal tools
Not logged in
Talk
Contributions
Create account
Log in
Namespaces
Article
Talk
Variants
Views
Read
Edit
View history
More
Search
Navigation
Main page
Contents
Featured content
Current events
Random article
Donate to Wikipedia
Wikipedia store
Interaction
Help
About Wikipedia
Community portal
Recent changes
Contact page
Tools
What links here
Related changes
Upload file
Special pages
Permanent link
Page information
Wikidata item
Cite this page
Print/export
Create a book
Download as PDF
Printable version
In other projects
Wikimedia Commons
Languages
العربية
Català
Čeština
Dansk
Deutsch
Eesti
Español
Euskara
Français
한국어
Italiano
Қазақша
Македонски
Nederlands
日本語
Norsk nynorsk
Polski
Português
Română
Русский
Simple English
Suomi
Svenska
Türkçe
Українська
中文
17 more
Edit links
This page was last edited on 24 April 2018, at 18:55.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia® is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization.
Privacy policy
About Wikipedia
Disclaimers
Contact Wikipedia
Developers
Cookie statement
Mobile view
Enable previews

key: html

type: local

value: div

attrs: id class

values: mw-page-base noprint

values: mw-head-base noprint

value: a

attrs: id class lang

values: firstHeading firstHeading en

values: siteSub noprint

values: jump-to-nav mw-jump

value: b

value: sup

attrs: href title

value: p

values:
/wiki/Under_the_table
mw-redirect
Under the table

attrs: alt src width height class srcset data-file-width data-file-height

values:
/wiki/Developing_world
mw-redirect
Developing world

values:
/wiki/Industrial_sector
mw-redirect
Industrial sector

values:
/wiki/Street_vendor
mw-redirect
Street vendor

values:
/wiki/Street_vendors
mw-redirect
Street vendors

values:
/wiki/Hernando_de_Soto_(economist)
mw-redirect
Hernando de Soto (economist)

values: Edit section: Estimated size of countries' informal economy

values: Edit section: Comparison of shadow economies in EU countries according to estimates by Friedrich Schneider

attrs: alt src width height srcset data-file-width data-file-height

values: The total national GDP of EU countries, and its formal and informal (shadow economy) component per capita[35][40]

values: Edit section: Social and political implications and issues

values:
/wiki/Public_services
mw-redirect
Public services

values:
/wiki/Domestic_workers
mw-redirect
Domestic workers

values:
/wiki/Labor_markets
mw-redirect
Labor markets

values: plainlinks metadata ambox ambox-content ambox-Original_research

values:
/wiki/Industrial_sectors
mw-redirect
Industrial sectors

values:
/wiki/Labor_force
mw-redirect
Labor force

values:
/wiki/Single_European_Market
mw-redirect
Single European Market

values:
/wiki/Treaty_of_Maastricht
mw-redirect
Treaty of Maastricht

values: display:table-cell;padding:0.2em 0.2em 0.2em 0.3em;vertical-align:middle

values: margin:0.5em 0 0.5em 1em;border:solid #aaa 1px

values:
/wiki/Casual_employment
mw-redirect
Casual employment

values:
/wiki/Doing_business_as
mw-redirect
Doing business as

values:
/wiki/Legal_personality
mw-redirect
Legal personality

values:
nofollow
external text
http://www.economist.com/node/2766310

values:
nofollow
external text
http://www.rrojasdatabank.info/sida.pdf

values:
/wiki/International_Labour_Organisation
mw-redirect
International Labour Organisation

values:
nofollow
external text
//doi.org/10.1017%2Fs0022278x00008089

values:
nofollow
external text
//www.jstor.org/stable/159873

values:
/wiki/R._Swedberg
mw-redirect
R. Swedberg

values:
nofollow
external text
//www.amazon.com/dp/0465016103

values:
nofollow
external text
//ssrn.com/abstract=2728060

attrs: alt src title width height srcset data-file-width data-file-height

values:
nofollow
external text
http://ftp.iza.org/dp6423.pdf

values:
nofollow
external text
http://ftp.iza.org/dp6891.pdf

values: -moz-column-width: 30em; -webkit-column-width: 30em; column-width: 30em; list-style-type: decimal;

values:
nofollow
external text
//doi.org/10.1525%2Fcity.1987.1.1.6

values:
nofollow
external text
http://www.community-links.org

values:
nofollow
external text
http://www.thememorybank.co.uk

values:
nofollow
external text
//doi.org/10.2202%2F1940-0004.1083

values:
nofollow
external free
https://doi.org/10.15173/glj.v7i1.2545

values:
nofollow
external text
http://www.undp.org/legalempowerment

values: Category:All articles with dead external links

values: Category:Articles with dead external links from October 2016

values: Category:Pages using web citations with no URL

values: Category:Articles that may contain original research from April 2018

values: Category:All articles that may contain original research

values: Discussion about edits from this IP address [ctrl-alt-n]

values: A list of edits made from this IP address [ctrl-alt-y]

values: You are encouraged to create an account and log in; however, it is not mandatory

values: You're encouraged to log in; however, it's not mandatory. [ctrl-alt-o]

values:
/wiki/Informal_sector
View the content page [ctrl-alt-c]
c

values: Discussion about the content page [ctrl-alt-t]

values: p-namespaces navigation vectorTabs p-namespaces-label

values:
p-variants
navigation
vectorMenu emptyPortlet
p-variants-label

values: Past revisions of this page [ctrl-alt-h]

values: p-views navigation vectorTabs p-views-label

values:
p-cactions
navigation
vectorMenu emptyPortlet
p-cactions-label

values:
mw-wiki-logo
/wiki/Main_Page
Visit the main page

values:
/wiki/Main_Page
Visit the main page [ctrl-alt-z]
z

values: Featured content – the best of Wikipedia

values: Find background information on current events

values:
/wiki/Special:Random
Load a random article [ctrl-alt-x]
x

values: portal navigation p-navigation p-navigation-label

values: Guidance on how to use and edit Wikipedia

values: About the project, what you can do, where to find things

values: A list of recent changes in the wiki [ctrl-alt-r]

values: portal navigation p-interaction p-interaction-label

values: List of all English Wikipedia pages containing links to this page [ctrl-alt-j]

values: Recent changes in pages linked from this page [ctrl-alt-k]

values:
/wiki/Wikipedia:File_Upload_Wizard
Upload files [ctrl-alt-u]
u

values: A list of all special pages [ctrl-alt-q]

values: Permanent link to this revision of the page

values: Link to connected data repository item [ctrl-alt-g]

values: Printable version of this page [ctrl-alt-p]

values: portal navigation p-wikibase-otherprojects p-wikibase-otherprojects-label

values: اقتصاد غير رسمي – Arabic

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-ca
display: none;

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-cs
display: none;

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-da
display: none;

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-et
display: none;

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-eu
display: none;

values: 비공식 부문 – Korean

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-it
display: none;

values: Жалған экономика – Kazakh

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-kk
display: none;

values: Сива економија – Macedonian

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-mk
display: none;

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-nl
display: none;

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-nn
display: none;

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-pl
display: none;

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-ro
display: none;

values: Неформальная экономика – Russian

values: interlanguage-link interwiki-ru badge-Q17437798 badge-goodarticle

values:
interlanguage-link interwiki-simple
display: none;

values: Неформальна економіка – Ukrainian

values: mediawiki ltr sitedir-ltr mw-hide-empty-elt ns-0 ns-subject page-Informal_sector rootpage-Informal_sector skin-vector action-view