AI Can Learn Scientific Taste
Great scientists have strong judgement and foresight, closely tied to what we call scientific taste. Here, we use the term to refer to the capacity to judge and propose research ideas with high potential impact. However, most relative research focuses on improving an AI scientist's executive capability, while enhancing an AI's scientific taste remains underexplored. In this work, we propose Reinforcement Learning from Community Feedback (RLCF), a training paradigm that uses large-scale community signals as supervision, and formulate scientific taste learning as a preference modeling and alignment problem. For preference modeling, we train Scientific Judge on 700K field- and time-matched pairs of high- vs. low-citation papers to judge ideas. For preference alignment, using Scientific Judge as a reward model, we train a policy model, Scientific Thinker, to propose research ideas with high potential impact. Experiments show Scientific Judge outperforms SOTA LLMs (e.g., GPT-5.2, Gemini 3 Pro) and generalizes to future-year test, unseen fields, and peer-review preference. Furthermore, Scientific Thinker proposes research ideas with higher potential impact than baselines. Our findings show that AI can learn scientific taste, marking a key step toward reaching human-level AI scientists.
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc38e
Jingqi Tong
claimed_verified
2026-03-19T13:03:46.169Z
64a7e7b2ef22f9c793e01454
/avatars/cd3706ffedbf68f58a8e53046008b7fb.svg
tongjingqi(SII)
tongjingqi
user
tongjingqi
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc38f
Mingzhe Li
claimed_verified
2026-03-17T08:20:34.062Z
65e4134472e748aae53e24f3
https://cdn-avatars.huggingface.co/v1/production/uploads/65e4134472e748aae53e24f3/H-aNcJFvGsoHpwNcfT6KK.jpeg
Mingzhe Li
Mubuky
user
Mubuky
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc390
Hangcheng Li
claimed_verified
2026-03-17T09:37:47.927Z
6690e13ccbcaf7ab0ec1c971
https://cdn-avatars.huggingface.co/v1/production/uploads/noauth/e8KDV6J29tviXlIpLZPq6.png
Tony.Li
lkdhy
user
lkdhy
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc391
Yongzhuo Yang
claimed_verified
2026-03-17T17:34:45.677Z
65ab2dd614d782df061265cd
https://cdn-avatars.huggingface.co/v1/production/uploads/65ab2dd614d782df061265cd/7T8kMx0wFNTa5zsVQrnOr.jpeg
Yongzhuo Yang
YangYongzhuo
user
YangYongzhuo
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc392
Yurong Mou
admin_assigned
2026-03-17T08:36:50.279Z
683029a472a7ad4f6382d490
/avatars/f7fae0899f2dfc468e2848b5569e23b3.svg
Yurong Mou
1v1-j12
user
1v1-j12
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc393
Weijie Ma
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc394
Zhiheng Xi
admin_assigned
2026-03-17T08:37:06.657Z
653a6e5cae155b92bae77b74
https://cdn-avatars.huggingface.co/v1/production/uploads/653a6e5cae155b92bae77b74/TA5FWKAUsB249ux4MzD_R.jpeg
Zhiheng Xi
WooooDyy
user
WooooDyy
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc395
Hongji Chen
claimed_verified
2026-03-17T17:34:47.501Z
68f4a0f45c7bd0ce4dce25fe
https://cdn-avatars.huggingface.co/v1/production/uploads/68f4a0f45c7bd0ce4dce25fe/DwD4GumMrJ5c8hz-n8e7D.jpeg
Hongji Chen
realZillionX
user
realZillionX
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc396
Xiaoran Liu
claimed_verified
2026-03-23T10:59:07.906Z
64f033ef82c6eea604c4da8b
/avatars/51b93fea7fd68b4274ee03701245dcca.svg
Xiaoran Liu (SII)
SII-xrliu
user
SII-xrliu
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc397
Qinyuan Cheng
admin_assigned
2026-03-17T08:36:20.211Z
695757e4fd9dc6e9bac27935
https://cdn-avatars.huggingface.co/v1/production/uploads/noauth/_uZEu4oOlKJVYqrG763Z-.jpeg
aa
qinyuancheng
user
qinyuancheng
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc398
Ming Zhang
claimed_verified
2026-03-18T08:46:20.392Z
65b71c0582d38451342f7334
/avatars/f9763a0ac361c350e6c6732e23564567.svg
Ming Zhang
konglongge
user
konglongge
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc399
Qiguang Chen
admin_assigned
2026-03-17T08:37:23.656Z
636f526a6cd69d9a36ff2b53
/avatars/8f2271a193fcac609d9be270552b5afa.svg
Qiguang Chen
LightChen2333
user
LightChen2333
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc39a
Weifeng Ge
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc39b
Qipeng Guo
admin_assigned
2026-03-17T08:37:35.612Z
6491cd52b1e5d3444528edb1
/avatars/a85635d886c7f157b6723dec5c01c030.svg
Qipeng Guo
QipengGuo
user
QipengGuo
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc39c
Tianlei Ying
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc39d
Tianxiang Sun
admin_assigned
2026-03-17T08:37:42.813Z
618c9e4cf35289d4bcab9d02
/avatars/28b5b096190b539295ec0da167f1abf3.svg
Tianxiang Sun (SII & Analemma)
txsun
user
txsun
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc39e
Yining Zheng
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc39f
Xinchi Chen
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc3a0
Jun Zhao
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc3a1
Ning Ding
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc3a2
Xuanjing Huang
admin_assigned
2026-03-17T08:35:57.679Z
67f9c4ee171948c38302ae0f
https://cdn-avatars.huggingface.co/v1/production/uploads/no-auth/Cqb3ijr_sZkpLhEEEEybK.png
Xuanjing Huang
xjhuang
user
xjhuang
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc3a3
Yugang Jiang
69b8b8746b3f36c249fbc3a4
Xipeng Qiu
admin_assigned
2026-03-17T08:35:47.982Z
61457b8deff2c9fdb4de4988
https://cdn-avatars.huggingface.co/v1/production/uploads/1632381702899-61457b8deff2c9fdb4de4988.jpeg
Xipeng Qiu
xpqiu
user
xpqiu
AI Can Learn Scientific Taste
Great scientists have strong judgement and foresight, closely tied to what we call scientific taste. Here, we use the term to refer to the capacity to judge and propose research ideas with high potential impact. However, most relative research focuses on improving an AI scientist's executive capability, while enhancing an AI's scientific taste remains underexplored. In this work, we propose Reinforcement Learning from Community Feedback (RLCF), a training paradigm that uses large-scale community signals as supervision, and formulate scientific taste learning as a preference modeling and alignment problem. For preference modeling, we train Scientific Judge on 700K field- and time-matched pairs of high- vs. low-citation papers to judge ideas. For preference alignment, using Scientific Judge as a reward model, we train a policy model, Scientific Thinker, to propose research ideas with high potential impact. Experiments show Scientific Judge outperforms SOTA LLMs (e.g., GPT-5.2, Gemini 3 Pro) and generalizes to future-year test, unseen fields, and peer-review preference. Furthermore, Scientific Thinker proposes research ideas with higher potential impact than baselines. Our findings show that AI can learn scientific taste, marking a key step toward reaching human-level AI scientists.