Sparse but Critical: A Token-Level Analysis of Distributional Shifts in RLVR Fine-Tuning of LLMs
Reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards (RLVR) has significantly improved reasoning in large language models (LLMs), yet the token-level mechanisms underlying these improvements remain unclear. We present a systematic empirical study of RLVR's distributional effects organized around three main analyses: (1) token-level characterization of distributional shifts between base and RL models, (2) the impact of token-level distributional shifts on sequence-level reasoning performance through cross-sampling interventions, and (3) fine-grained mechanics of these shifts at the token level. We find that RL fine-tuning induces highly sparse and targeted changes, with only a small fraction of token distributions exhibiting meaningful divergence between the base and RL policies. We further characterize the structure and evolution of these shifts through analyses of token entropy, positional concentration, and reallocation of probability mass. To assess the functional importance of these sparse changes, we conduct cross-sampling experiments that selectively swap token choices between the base and RL models with varying intervention budgets. We show that inserting only a small fraction of RL-sampled tokens into base generations progressively recovers RL performance gains, while injecting a similarly small number of base token choices into otherwise RL-generated sequences collapses performance to base levels, isolating a small set of token-level decisions directly responsible for RLVR's performance gains. Finally, we explore divergence-weighted variants of the advantage signal as a diagnostic intervention, finding that they can yield improvements over baselines. Together, our results shed light on the distributional changes induced by RLVR and provide a fine-grained, token-level lens for understanding RLVR fine-tuning as a targeted refinement process.
69c3493c95b48f16a30077bb
Haoming Meng
69c3493c95b48f16a30077bc
Kexin Huang
claimed_verified
2026-03-30T09:10:31.716Z
6547a247dbce6bd2be168d33
/avatars/23ae384f7c4fc1a89a556a37f5e75acf.svg
Kexin Huang
737443h
user
737443h
69c3493c95b48f16a30077bd
Shaohang Wei
69c3493c95b48f16a30077be
Chiyu Ma
69c3493c95b48f16a30077bf
Shuo Yang
claimed_verified
2026-04-01T08:36:22.595Z
656aa5dd3dc1d277e5214144
/avatars/32eb7d1f0a505fb853a1722f9ff655bd.svg
Shuo Yang
ShuoY
user
ShuoY
69c3493c95b48f16a30077c0
Xue Wang
69c3493c95b48f16a30077c1
Guoyin Wang
69c3493c95b48f16a30077c2
Bolin Ding
69c3493c95b48f16a30077c3
Jingren Zhou
Sparse but Critical: A Token-Level Analysis of Distributional Shifts in RLVR Fine-Tuning of LLMs
Reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards (RLVR) has significantly improved reasoning in large language models (LLMs), yet the token-level mechanisms underlying these improvements remain unclear. We present a systematic empirical study of RLVR's distributional effects organized around three main analyses: (1) token-level characterization of distributional shifts between base and RL models, (2) the impact of token-level distributional shifts on sequence-level reasoning performance through cross-sampling interventions, and (3) fine-grained mechanics of these shifts at the token level. We find that RL fine-tuning induces highly sparse and targeted changes, with only a small fraction of token distributions exhibiting meaningful divergence between the base and RL policies. We further characterize the structure and evolution of these shifts through analyses of token entropy, positional concentration, and reallocation of probability mass. To assess the functional importance of these sparse changes, we conduct cross-sampling experiments that selectively swap token choices between the base and RL models with varying intervention budgets. We show that inserting only a small fraction of RL-sampled tokens into base generations progressively recovers RL performance gains, while injecting a similarly small number of base token choices into otherwise RL-generated sequences collapses performance to base levels, isolating a small set of token-level decisions directly responsible for RLVR's performance gains. Finally, we explore divergence-weighted variants of the advantage signal as a diagnostic intervention, finding that they can yield improvements over baselines. Together, our results shed light on the distributional changes induced by RLVR and provide a fine-grained, token-level lens for understanding RLVR fine-tuning as a targeted refinement process.
Reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards induces sparse, targeted changes in token distributions that can be systematically analyzed through distributional shifts and cross-sampling interventions to understand performance gains.
reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards token-level mechanisms distributional shifts cross-sampling interventions token entropy positional concentration probability mass reallocation advantage signal