Dataset Viewer
Duplicate
The dataset viewer is not available for this split.
Cannot extract the features (columns) for the split 'train' of the config 'default' of the dataset.
Error code:   FeaturesError
Exception:    ArrowInvalid
Message:      Schema at index 1 was different: 
band: int64
prompts_passing: int64
of: int64
prompts: string
vs
prompt_id: string
n_machine_in_word_corridor: int64
chars_lo: int64
chars_hi: int64
Traceback:    Traceback (most recent call last):
                File "/src/services/worker/src/worker/job_runners/split/first_rows.py", line 244, in compute_first_rows_from_streaming_response
                  iterable_dataset = iterable_dataset._resolve_features()
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/iterable_dataset.py", line 4523, in _resolve_features
                  features = _infer_features_from_batch(self.with_format(None)._head())
                                                        ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^^
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/iterable_dataset.py", line 2768, in _head
                  return next(iter(self.iter(batch_size=n)))
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/iterable_dataset.py", line 2972, in iter
                  for key, pa_table in ex_iterable.iter_arrow():
                                       ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^^
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/iterable_dataset.py", line 2483, in _iter_arrow
                  yield from self.ex_iterable._iter_arrow()
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/iterable_dataset.py", line 591, in _iter_arrow
                  yield new_key, pa.Table.from_batches(chunks_buffer)
                                 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
                File "pyarrow/table.pxi", line 5012, in pyarrow.lib.Table.from_batches
                File "pyarrow/error.pxi", line 155, in pyarrow.lib.pyarrow_internal_check_status
                File "pyarrow/error.pxi", line 92, in pyarrow.lib.check_status
                  raise convert_status(status)
              pyarrow.lib.ArrowInvalid: Schema at index 1 was different: 
              band: int64
              prompts_passing: int64
              of: int64
              prompts: string
              vs
              prompt_id: string
              n_machine_in_word_corridor: int64
              chars_lo: int64
              chars_hi: int64

Need help to make the dataset viewer work? Make sure to review how to configure the dataset viewer, and open a discussion for direct support.

Equal Scores, Unequal Choices — data

Data for the paper Equal Scores, Unequal Choices: LLM Judges Favour Machine-Written Essays. LLM judges score (1–6) and choose between student essays from PERSUADE 2.0 and ASAP 2.0, which trained raters scored on the same holistic scale, and machine-written essays for the same prompts.

The accompanying code (https://anonymous.4open.science/r/essay-judges-2C42/) reads this directory as its data/ folder: make paper rebuilds every table, figure and number of the paper from results/, and make analyses recomputes results/ from the judge answers in judgments/.

Contents

Path Rows What
prompts/ 15 The writing prompts: 8 PERSUADE 2.0 independent prompts and 7 ASAP 2.0 source-based prompts with their source texts.
human/ 37,848 Student essays with the trained raters' holistic score (quality_score, 1–6).
essays/raw/ 840 Machine-written essays (14 models, default generation), as generated.
essays/normalized/ 38,688 Human and machine essays after the same form-only normalization (text_normalized).
essays/variants/*.parquet Rewritten and degraded essays, keyed to their source essay (source_id): g2, g2b (machine essays rewritten in a student's style), g3 (human essays polished by a model), d1 (machine essays with student-rate surface errors), d2 (content weakened, with surface errors), d3 (d2 with paragraphs shuffled), lc (human essays with spelling, grammar and punctuation corrected), nt (essays rewritten in plain standard English).
judgments/<name>/calls.jsonl 150,072 Every judge answer, one JSON object per request (see below).
results/ Every analysis output the paper is built from.

Parquet tables in prompts/, human/ and essays/ carry a manifest.json (row counts, schema, checksums).

Judge answers

Each line of judgments/<name>/calls.jsonl is one request to one judge:

  • _key: experiment (arm code; see src/essay_judges/judging/units.py in the code), judge (model), kind (point for a 1–6 score, choice for picking the best of several essays), pool (the essay or pool id) and order (presentation order);
  • candidates: essay ids in the order shown; display_ids: the opaque ids the judge saw; labels: authorship labels shown, if any; condition: the prompt condition (e.g. a remedy);
  • prompt_id, prompt (the full request text), prompt_sha256;
  • raw (the judge's reply), value (the parsed score or chosen id), status (valid or the reason the answer is invalid), detail, error, finish_reason;
  • response_id: an anonymised identifier of the response, distinct for every model call.
Name Content
pointwise_main, pointwise_pool_judges, pointwise_flagships, pointwise_gemma_26b, pointwise_size_ladders, pointwise_qwen, pointwise_haiku, pointwise_reasoning_low 1–6 scores of human and machine essays by each judge panel
pointwise_rewrites, pointwise_mechanism_items scores of rewritten, corrected and neutrally rewritten essays
pointwise_repeats further independent repeats of identical scoring requests (test-retest noise)
pools_six_and_labels, pools_six_flagships one-best choice among six essays, with and without authorship labels
equal_score_degraded, equal_score_pairs, equal_score_controls, equal_score_gap_controls, equal_score_size_ladders the equal-score test: human–machine pairs the judge scored equally, same-class control pairs, degraded pairs, harder and rubric pools
pools_k, odd_one_out pools of up to ten candidates and all their pairs
remedies, reasoning_pairs prompt-level remedies; judges at low reasoning effort
neutral_rewrite_and_error_dose, neutral_rewrite_and_error_dose_sonnet neutrally rewritten pools; essays as written, lightly corrected and polished
size_ladder_pairs_qwen, size_ladder_pairs_haiku the equal-score pairs for further models of the size ladders

Not included

  • Per-essay demographics of PERSUADE 2.0 (English-learner and economic status), used for the group gaps at equal rater band. Only aggregates are reported; the code fetches the per-essay fields from the original release.
  • BAWE essays (British Academic Written English corpus), whose terms do not allow redistribution. They supply part of the reference vocabulary of one feature (misspellings) of the machine-likeness classifier; the computed features are in results/.

Sources and licence

Human essays and prompts come from:

  • PERSUADE 2.0 — Crossley et al. (2024), A large-scale corpus for assessing written argumentation: PERSUADE 2.0, Assessing Writing 61. Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.
  • ASAP 2.0 — Crossley et al. (2025), A large-scale corpus for assessing source-based writing quality: ASAP 2.0, Assessing Writing 65. Part of its essays also appear in PERSUADE 2.0.

This dataset is released under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, the licence of PERSUADE 2.0, which the human essays, the prompts and the judge requests (which contain essay texts) inherit. Machine-written essays and judge answers were produced through the providers' APIs for research use.

Downloads last month
41